Note: This is an archived topic. It is read-only.
  CL Sailboats Online Forum
  Miscellaneous
  MSDs vs Porta-Potties (Page 2)

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!

profile | register | preferences | faq | search


This topic is 2 pages long:   1  2 
This topic was originally posted in this forum: CL User Forum
Author Topic:   MSDs vs Porta-Potties
Eric
Member
posted October 27, 2004 08:10 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Eric   Click Here to Email Eric     
More likely it was the weekend warriers in powerboats;D, that and the fact that we like to ensure clean water, is the reason why we have such laws

Eric

[This message has been edited by Eric (edited October 28, 2004).]

SuperPiper
Member
posted October 29, 2004 11:03 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for SuperPiper     
Yeah, but. . .

There are no pump-out facilities on our cottage lake. I would tell the OPP that the port-a-potti is better than hanging over the transom.

I will need to fix my head in place and add pump-out connections if I trailer away from the land-locked lake. Are detachable hoses legal?

Darcy
Member
posted October 29, 2004 03:02 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Darcy   Click Here to Email Darcy     
I've disconnected our pipes. So I guess I could remove the head and take it to a pump out facility on a bigger lake. But at that point I could just empty the contents into our shore based toilet.

Just make sure you re-connect securely

D'Arcy

Shortstay
Member
posted October 29, 2004 04:02 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Shortstay   Click Here to Email Shortstay     
For any American sailors (and Ontarian scufflaws!) who just want the porta (and not the MSD), I saw the Thetford 135 at WalMart today for just under $70... Sorry, my law-abiding Ontario friends.



SuperPiper
Member
posted November 14, 2004 12:31 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for SuperPiper     
I apologize for stirring this up again.

But, in Elmet3's Oct 24 post there was the phrase: "All parts of the system . . . are congruent . . ." Does that mean that the discharge hose could not be made detachable? Would it be possible to stow the hose when it was not in use?

I also have a VIP-8L from Sanitation Equipment. It fit the old installation perfectly. I am now trying to convert it to a proper MSD. I have sent an e-mail to sanitationequipment@sympatico.ca.

If a removable hose is legal, I intend to camlock it to the deck fitting and drop the other end through the toilet bowl's flush valve. The VIP-8L does not have a hose connection. The discharge cap is covered by the removable bowl and fresh water reservoir.

[This message has been edited by SuperPiper (edited November 14, 2004).]

Eric
Member
posted November 14, 2004 10:11 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Eric   Click Here to Email Eric     
Sounds like an interesting plan.

Keep us up to date on your progress.

Eric

CoolBreeze
Member
posted November 14, 2004 10:19 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for CoolBreeze   Click Here to Email CoolBreeze     
I have the same VIP 8L unit.... Please let me know how you make out. Can you drop me a line at robertbelliveau @ eastlink.ca With some pics of your install....
Thanks

------------------
Rob Belliveau
1976 Sandpiper 565
"Cool Breeze"
Halifax NS
Soon to be at DYC


SuperPiper
Member
posted November 18, 2004 04:22 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for SuperPiper     
Rob:

Sanitation Equipment faxed the following letter. I think that it requires some studying and some interpretation. According to the letter, the pump-out hose does not need to be permanently attached. I have some ideas of my own that I am working on.

We are happy to hear that you are so pleased with your VIP8L toilet.

To use your VIP 8L, you would have to do the following.........

1- Install the VIP8L into the boat with permanent brackets. MSRP $22.28
2- Install a deck fitting for pump-out if not already in place.
3- Purchase a pump-out plate for the 8L marine version. MSRP $17.66
4- Purchase a pour spout assembly for one of the larger models. MSRP $17.73

What this will enable you to do is to utilize your 8L toilet and when required, remove the bowl assembly, remove the holding tank cap and replace the cap with the pump-out plate. The unit can then be pumped out through the deck fitting installed. When pumping out is complete, remove the pump-out plate assembly and reattach the holding tank cap. Then tread the pump-out plate onto the pour spout assembly for when it is not in use. This will protect anything from coming into contact with the pump-out plate that was just in your waste tank as well as any odours that may be present.

This is the only idea I have if you do not wish to purchase a marine toilet for the application but in parts alone, you're already over $50.00 plus taxes, shipping etc.

Good Luck. Please contact us if we can be of any further assistance.

David Fleming I.E.T.
Q.A./ Engineering Manager
Sanitation Equipment Limited

[This message has been edited by SuperPiper (edited November 18, 2004).]

CoolBreeze
Member
posted November 18, 2004 02:08 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for CoolBreeze   Click Here to Email CoolBreeze     
Hmmm.... I have a line run to the deck as a pump out from the existing blue bucket that is there. Are these parts available over the net? Or 1-800 # ??? Very interesting... I'd like to see a diagram.

------------------
Rob Belliveau
1976 Sandpiper 565
"Cool Breeze"
Halifax NS
Soon to be at DYC


SuperPiper
Member
posted November 19, 2004 04:38 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for SuperPiper     
Rob:

Here is an idea for you.

The drain in the bottom of the blue bucket comes apart like a bathtub or wash basin drain. That is, the chromed piece on the inside of the bucket unscrews from the cast bronze tailpiece under the bucket. So if you choose, you could drill a hole the same diameter in the same relative location into the bottom of the VIP 8L and re-install the existing drain.

Job done.

I am considering something a little more complicated for my boat. The pumpout hose was completely removed a few years ago. I will post a cartoon of my proposed installation for the group to comment.

[This message has been edited by SuperPiper (edited November 19, 2004).]

SuperPiper
Member
posted November 19, 2004 12:20 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for SuperPiper     


[This message has been edited by SuperPiper (edited November 19, 2004).]

[This message has been edited by SuperPiper (edited November 19, 2004).]

Ken
Member
posted February 11, 2005 05:49 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Ken   Click Here to Email Ken     
Just found this Federal link:

http://www.tc.gc.ca/acts-regulations/GENERAL/C/CSA/regulations/090/csa091/csa91.html

CoolBreeze
Member
posted February 13, 2005 06:31 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for CoolBreeze   Click Here to Email CoolBreeze     
I wonder how much trimming would be needed to fit my VIP 8L into the "blue bucket" area. I really don't like the thought of cutting into areas that were designed to keep the boat afloat, like flotation compartments. Do the edges of the bucket border directly on other flotation compartment walls?

------------------
Rob Belliveau
1976 Sandpiper 565
"Cool Breeze"
Halifax NS
Soon to be at DYC


Eric
Member
posted February 13, 2005 07:27 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Eric   Click Here to Email Eric     
Hey Rob, I'm replacing my "bucket" this spring. I made an exploratory cut into the bucket, and it appears the foam is pretty much moulded around the bucket. I asked CL what was in there while at the boat show, and I was told there should be a plywood base under the bucket.
Nevertheless, once I remove the bucket, I'll make the opening large enough to fit the new MSD. I'll probably fit plywood and glass over the cut out, ready to accept the new head.
It'll be nice if the weather could warm up for a couple of days during my days off, so I can get an early start at this .
Eric

[This message has been edited by Eric (edited February 13, 2005).]

CoolBreeze
Member
posted February 13, 2005 09:11 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for CoolBreeze   Click Here to Email CoolBreeze     
Well, I've never been one to re-write the book, so I think I'll stay tuned to your "exploration".

My initial thoughts would be that if there seems to be no fibreglas barrier between the bucket and floatation filling, there would be no issue with taking out the bucket and simply trimming to make a MSD unit fit. Are you planning on putting a VIP 8L as well? I think I will do this modification as well, I know the "factory" plumbing (unlike many it seems) is still there. I would look at hooking it up on the bottom of the unit as mentioned a couple posts back.

I'm sure you'll keep us updated, pics would be GREAT too!!

------------------
Rob Belliveau
1976 Sandpiper 565
"Cool Breeze"
Halifax NS
Soon to be at DYC


whited
unregistered
posted February 13, 2005 09:20 AM           
What is this 'blue bucket' business? I don't recall seeing anything like that on my boat.


CoolBreeze
Member
posted February 13, 2005 11:35 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for CoolBreeze   Click Here to Email CoolBreeze     
It is what the designers used as a head in (i am guessing only some) Sandpipers. It is located at the foot of the "v-berth" just ahead of the table. Mine is somewhat flush with the berths. It has a cover, no "seat". It has a drain at the bottom that is connected to a line that would have exited up by the anchor chamber on deck. Mine still has the bucket and its original plumbing. The downside to this set up, is that there is no holding tank. All the waste is held in this bucket until drained. So, needless to say, you can imagine some of the issues that may arise with this set up.

------------------
Rob Belliveau
1976 Sandpiper 565
"Cool Breeze"
Halifax NS
Soon to be at DYC


Eric
Member
posted February 13, 2005 12:04 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Eric   Click Here to Email Eric     
Queitwaters Sailboats in Waubaushene ON has a 'piper with a porta potti, for sale. I'm going to go and have a gander at it, maybe snap a pick, and report back.
I was lead to believe it's a factory job.


whited
unregistered
posted February 13, 2005 01:14 PM           
My piper has a neat little space molded in just the right size for my VISA MSD in that spot. I don't have any pictures, as I just rec'd my new digital camera at Christmas and the boat is covered by it's tarp.
I'll make up for lost time on the picture side soon.


SuperPiper
Member
posted February 14, 2005 04:38 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for SuperPiper     
I would have cleaned if I had known you were coming. Excuse the dust - there's construction going on.

The VIP-8L fit perfectly in my Sandpiper. The blue pot was removed and the liner was cut out to the full extent of the recess. The head has to be tilted flush-side-first into the cutout.

I did not find a piece of plywood under the blue pot. There was just the expanded foam supporting the fixture. So, I trimmed it flat, made a 3-sided styrofoam box and finished the enclosure.

You may notice that the expanded foam completely filled the port side at the access port. But, the starboard side was less than full. I may take advantage of this void to make a hose connection to the head.

[This message has been edited by SuperPiper (edited February 14, 2005).]

CoolBreeze
Member
posted February 14, 2005 08:09 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for CoolBreeze   Click Here to Email CoolBreeze     
How much trimming did you have to do once you removed the bucket? did you have to do much fobreglas work?. It looks like the VIP 8L fits right in. It also looks like it is a perfect height. What was your reasoning for the two access holes? I think the majority of the factory plumbing is on the starboard side, which would be good, if there seems to be less floatation filling there. A hook up into the pottie would seem fairly easy.

Great pics and great work, that is exactly how I hoped it would fit

------------------
Rob Belliveau
1976 Sandpiper 565
"Cool Breeze"
Halifax NS
Soon to be at DYC


Hyprstitch
Member
posted February 14, 2005 08:36 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Hyprstitch   Click Here to Email Hyprstitch     
Most of the Lakes in Colorado are small so I've not needed to use my Port a Pottie to speak of. And it is a Port a Pottie, not built in. It does sit in place where it is meant to be. The couple of times its been needed I've moved it to the center of the cabin to use.
Reason being, it can't be hardly used where it belongs, not enough head room. You can open the hatch and that would help, but not while under sail.

What I'm asking. have any of you tried to use yours? You might want to see how it will work before you go through the trouble of a fixed install.

Sid

Eric
Member
posted February 14, 2005 10:38 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Eric   Click Here to Email Eric     
Superpiper, thanks for posting the great pics.
Where did you get the new port a pottie? I'm assuming it can be fitted with pump out plumbing.
Eric


Patrick Crooks
Member
posted February 14, 2005 11:41 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Patrick Crooks   Click Here to Email Patrick Crooks     
I take it there was a change in designs at some point. I have a complete opening (Open from the top and front) in the area for the head. Almost like it was designed for a true marine wet/dry head.


whited
unregistered
posted February 14, 2005 01:14 PM           
You are right Patrick. That's the way my 1986 model is. You see the entire front of the MSD and I have been thinking of installing a true marine head like all the other sailboats here on the East coast.


Shortstay
Member
posted February 16, 2005 05:08 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Shortstay   Click Here to Email Shortstay     
quote:
Originally posted by Patrick Crooks:
I take it there was a change in designs at some point. I have a complete opening (Open from the top and front) in the area for the head. Almost like it was designed for a true marine wet/dry head.

Ditto here too, Patrick. Shortstay's an '81. There's a ridge on the floor of the cabin right along the front edge of the head to keep it from sliding aft.

Ken
Member
posted April 05, 2005 04:51 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Ken   Click Here to Email Ken     
There's a Thetford 745 MSD for sale on EBay.
It's holding tank is larger then the 735MSD in ShortWave but the technology is the same.
The height will be proportionally...umm...a bit higher. Still worth considering 'tho.

Go to EBAY and search
THETFORD MARINE HEAD


whited
unregistered
posted April 05, 2005 05:11 PM           
Ken...the holding tank seems small on my MSD. How long could two people go between pumpouts?


Shortstay
Member
posted April 05, 2005 05:13 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Shortstay   Click Here to Email Shortstay     
Depends on how full of sh_t you are...



Windroos
Member
posted April 05, 2005 08:49 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Windroos   Click Here to Email Windroos     
Hi Superpiper

That's the first time I see a piper with such of an installation. Mine has a cavity where you place the can. I placed a little toilet from Canadian tire, 18 liter I guess. Work as magic.

I never saw either the 2 holes in the front. I have always wonder what things looked like under the front berth.

Tell me something please. If you pour water in one of theses holes, where would the water go?

I have sometimes a little bit of water in this section and I was asking myself if it could run as far as the back of the boat and freeze to crack everything during the winter.

I know the water seems to come from the evacuating hose on the deck. Gotta fix the problem this spring.

Thanks for the pictures.


------------------
John
Quebec city
1981 Sandpiper 927


Ken
Member
posted April 07, 2005 02:26 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Ken   Click Here to Email Ken     
Make sure that the head doesn't get overfilled, especially if you're heeling in strong winds. Discourage unsupervised head use by flush-happy youngsters. Use good quality dissolving tissue in moderate quantities. Our Thetford 735 MSD lasted 4-5 days when away from marina pumpout facilities in North Channel or lake Ontario's Prince Edward County.
Of course, if you pee over the side the head will last longer. Easier for men, but still do-able by hiking out over the cockpit coaming for unabashed females with a good sense of balance and strong abdominal muscles, and only a medium sense of decorum. Of course, while performing delecate operations such as this.....impromptu jybes or tacks by the skipper will be met with a shriek! Lynn once flashed a powerboat which skimmed too close past us in Georgian Bay North Channel. She was at the point-of-no-return stage when the cruiser went by. Perhaps they thought that it was some sort of a distress signal...they didn't stop!

Maybe they thought that we were a pirate ship......getting ready to keel haul a female captive?

[This message has been edited by Ken (edited April 07, 2005).]

Eric
Member
posted April 09, 2005 02:19 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Eric   Click Here to Email Eric     
LOL Ken Very funny story!!

Eric

windy island
Member
posted April 12, 2005 12:44 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for windy island   Click Here to Email windy island     
The ladies can do it to.LOL
whizzy4you.com
travelmateinfo.com


This topic is 2 pages long:   1  2 

All times are ET(US)

This is an ARCHIVED topic. You may not reply to it!
Hop to:

Contact Us | CL Sailboats: Online


Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.45b