posted January 26, 2005 08:07 PM
Hi. I'm a cruising sailor too. I've lot's of race experience (on a keelboat) in my past, but today, it's strictly sunday sailing.
The sail plan on my CL16 is identical to yours. I've noticed that the boat is nicely balanced with it and for this reason, I wouldn't recommend changing it. That is, unless you sail in an area with predominantly heavy winds where a smaller mainsail might be an option. In most cases, a reefed mainsail should suffice.
What's the problem with the large roach of the mainsail? Any change here will affect the light air performance and balance of the sailplan.
I have the same small headsail on a furler that you have described. I too have had the problem with the continuous-loop furling line and it's predisposition to slip on the reel. The solution here is more tension on the furling line. On my boat, this furling line is attached to the port side shroud with a heavy bungee cord. This cord tension the line so that there is no slack in it. If the furling line starts to slip, a little more tension with the bungee cord will cure the problem. Too much tension also is not a good thing. Experiment to find the happy medium and you'll find that the furler works like a charm. A little practice will also prevent the sail's wrapping on the forestay.
You mention the possibility of use of a hanked-on foresail. There's no reason you cannot do this. There will be an advantage in that you can use a larger, or smaller headsail if you wish. You'll also be able to tension the luff better which should result in a little better upwind performance. The downside is having to deal with a loose sail on the foredeck! The furling headsail is a far better option for a cruising sailor.
I too have had the problem of a jib sheet grabbing the haliard cleat on the mast when I tack. Generally, it's easily released but I recognize it could represent a capsize threat in heavy air. Moving the cleats is an option. Personally, it doesnt' happen often enough to make it worthwhile.
As others have mentioned, jiffy reefing is the usual option for the mainsail. It works so well, I don't know why one would consider anything else.
Happy sailing!