2007-08: Tonawanda (Wilke) def. St. Catharines (LaFontaine)
2006-07: Tonawanda (Wilke) def. Mammoth (Vyhnalek)
2005-06: St. Catharines (LaFontaine) def. Mammoth (Vyhnalek)
2004-05: Kansas City (Martin) def. East Aurora (Davis)
2003-04: East Aurora (Davis) def. St. Catharines (LaFontaine)
2002-03: East Aurora (Davis) def. Buffalo (Taylor)
2001-02: Buffalo (Taylor) def. East Aurora (Davis)
2000-01: Hagerstown (Brierley) def. Texas (Martin)
1999-00: Hagerstown (Brierley) def. Hershey (Wilke)
1998-99: BS Alliance (Taylor/Vallari) def. Black Rock (McKee)
1997-98: Hagerstown (Brierley) def. East Aurora (Davis)
1996-97: Hershey (Wilke) def. Steubenville (Taylor)
1995-96: East Aurora (Davis) def. Lackawanna (Liszewski)
1994-95: St. Louis (Liszewski) def. Steubenville (Taylor)
1993-94: St. Louis (Liszewski) def. Steubenville (Taylor)
1992-93: East Aurora (Davis) def. St. Louis (Liszewski)
1991-92: St. Louis (Liszewski) def. East Aurora (Davis)
1990-91: St. Louis (Liszewski) def. East Aurora (Davis)
1989-90: St. Louis (Liszewski) def. Geneva (Larush)